Topics
Latest
AI
Amazon
Image Credits:Kyle Wiggers / TechCrunch
Apps
Biotech & Health
mood
Image Credits:Kyle Wiggers / TechCrunch
Cloud Computing
Commerce
Crypto
“Pounamu,” about a young bird exploring the wider world.Image Credits:Samuel Schrag
Enterprise
EVs
Fintech
A scene from “Dear Mom.”Image Credits:Johans Saldana Guadalupe and Katie Luo
Fundraising
Gadgets
bet on
Giant grandmothers as imagined by AI.Image Credits:Léo Cannone
Government & Policy
computer hardware
A man wrestles with his emotions — literally — in “Get Me Out.”Image Credits:Daniel Antebi
layoff
Media & Entertainment
Meta
Microsoft
Privacy
Robotics
Security
Social
Space
startup
TikTok
deportation
speculation
More from TechCrunch
Events
Startup Battlefield
StrictlyVC
Podcasts
Videos
Partner Content
TechCrunch Brand Studio
Crunchboard
Contact Us
In the third episode of “ Creative Dialogues , ” an consultation series bring about by the filmmaking division of procreative AI startup Runway , multimedia artist Claire Hentschker expresses a fear that AI will commoditize the artistic cognitive operation to the point where nontextual matter homogenizes , relapse to a sort of derivative humdrum .
“ Are you stimulate this increasingly narrow norm of existing thing ? ” she asks . “ And then — as that keeps getting average out — is everything is just gon na be a blob ? ”
Those are the questions I kept asking myself Wednesday at a showing of the top 10 finalist at Runway ’s second annual AI Film Festival , which areavailable on - demandon Runway ’s website as of this morning .
Runway held two premiere this yr , one in Los Angeles and a second in New York . I attended New York ’s , which take property at Metrograph , a theater known for its arthouse and avant - garde bookings .
I ’m proud of to cover that AI is n’t hasten in a blob hereafter … not yet at least . But a skilled directorial heart — the human touch — attain a percipient difference in an “ AI film ’s ” effectiveness .
All of the picture show submitted to the festival incorporate AI in some human body , let in AI - return backdrops and animations , semisynthetic voice - over , and bullet time - style particular effect . None of the elements seemed quite to the level of what state - of - the - prowess tools likeOpenAI ’s Soracan produce , but that was to be expected , have that most of the submissions were finalize early in the year .
Indeed , it tended to be obvious — sometimes painfully so — which theatrical role of films were the product of an AI model , not an actor , cameraman or animator . Even otherwise inviolable script were sometimes permit down by underwhelming generative AI effects .
Join us at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
Exhibit at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
Take , for deterrent example , “ Dear Mom ” by Johans Saldana Guadalupe and Katie Luo , which recite the story of a daughter ’s be intimate family relationship with her female parent — in the daughter ’s own words . It ’s a tearjerker . But a scene of a Los Angeles freeway with all the telling weirdness of AI - generate telecasting ( e.g. , warped railcar , freakish physics ) broke the turn for me .
The limitations of today ’s AI tools seemed to box some film in .
As my colleagueDevin Coldewey of late wrote , moderate with productive models — specially video - sire ace — is baffling . Simple matters in traditional filmmaking , like choosing a colour in a fictitious character ’s clothing , require workarounds because each shot is make severally of the others . Sometimes not even workarounds do the trick .
The resulting disjointedness was on show at the fete , where several of the cinema were little more than tangentially related vignettes strung together by narration and a soundtrack . “ L’éveil à la création ” by Carlo De Togni and Elena Sparacino certify just how dim this recipe can be , with slideshow - like transitions that would make for a better interactive storybook than film .
Léo Cannone ’s “ Where Do Grandmas Go When They Get Lost ? ” fall into the vignettes family as well — but triumphs despite this thanks to a earnest script ( a tiddler delineate what take place to grandmothers after they pass ) and an exceptionally strong functioning from its kid star . The rest of the audience seemed to agree ; the film got one of the more spirited round of drinks of clapping of the night .
And for me , that really sums up the festival in a nutshell . The homo — not AI — contributions often make all the difference . The emotionality in a child role player ’s representative ? That sticks with you . AI - generated backdrop ? Less so .
This was sure as shooting true for fete Grand Prix succeeder “ Get Me Out , ” which document one Japanese man ’s struggle to recover from the psychological cost of his immigration to the U.S. as a young child . movie maker Daniel Antebi describe the man ’s panic tone-beginning with the assist of AI - generated graphics — graphics that I come up to be less successful , at long last , than the cinematography . The film terminate with a shot of the human being take the air up a bridge just as the street lamp dotting the pedestrian lane flicker on one by one . It ’s haunt — and beautiful — and surely took ages to capture just so .
It ’s very possible that generative AI will one 24-hour interval be able to re - make scenes like this . Perhaps cinematography will eventually be replaced with prompting — a victim of the ever - growing datasets ( albeit withtroubling right of first publication status ) on which startup such as Runway and OpenAI are training their video - generating model .
But that solar day is n’t today .
As the screening wind up and the honor recipients marched to the front of the dramatics for a picture op , I could n’t help but point out the cinematographer in the corner documenting the whole affair . Maybe , on the contrary , AI will never replace some things , like the humans we humans deeply hunger .
