Topics
Latest
AI
Amazon
Image Credits:Chona Kasinger/Bloomberg / Getty Images
Apps
Biotech & Health
Climate
Image Credits:Chona Kasinger/Bloomberg / Getty Images
Cloud Computing
Commerce
Crypto
Here is OpenAI’s answer to Google search.Image Credits:Maxwell Zeff/OpenAI
Enterprise
EVs
Fintech
Comparison of ChatGPT Search (left) and Google search (Right) for live NBA scores.Image Credits:Maxwell Zeff/OpenAI
Fundraising
Gadgets
Gaming
ChatGPT Search for “baggy denim jeans.”Image Credits:Maxwell Zeff/OpenAI
Government & Policy
Hardware
ChatGPT Search works well for longer questions.Image Credits:Maxwell Zeff/OpenAI
layoff
Media & Entertainment
ChatGPT search taps OpenAI’s news partners.Image Credits:Maxwell Zeff/OpenAI
Meta
Microsoft
Privacy
Robotics
Security
Social
distance
Startups
TikTok
Transportation
speculation
More from TechCrunch
Events
Startup Battlefield
StrictlyVC
Podcasts
Videos
Partner Content
TechCrunch Brand Studio
Crunchboard
Contact Us
Last week , OpenAI release its extremely anticipated search product , ChatGPT Search , to take on Google . The industry has been bracing for this import for months , prompting Google toinject AI - generated answer into its core productearlier this yr and producingsome embarrassing hallucinationsin the cognitive operation . That mishap led many hoi polloi to believe that OpenAI ’s hunt railway locomotive would truly be a “ Google grampus . ”
But after using ChatGPT Search as my nonpayment search engine ( you’re able to , too , withOpenAI ’s extension ) for roughly a mean solar day , I quickly switched back to Google . OpenAI ’s lookup production was impressive in some ways and volunteer a glimpse of what an AI - lookup user interface could one day look like . But for now , it ’s still too visionary to use as my day-after-day driver .
ChatGPT Search was now and again utilitarian for surfacing real - sentence answers to questions that I would have otherwise had to dig through many ads and SEO - optimized article to find . Like others in this AI search category like Perplexity and You.com , it presents concise answers in a nice data formatting : You get links to the data ’s seed on the right side ; the headline and short snippets give you a nimble reality stop on the AI - generated text edition .
However , it often just felt impractical for quotidian use .
In its current variety , ChatGPT Search is treacherous for what people use Google for the most : short , navigational query . inquiry short than four Word of God representthe bulk of searches on Google ; these are often just a few keywords that get you to the proper web page , often one the user knows but does n’t want to bother typing out . They ’re the kind of lookup most people are barely even conscious they ’re making all day , and it ’s what Google tend to do very well .
I ’m talk about “ Celtics score , ” “ cotton wool socks , ” “ library hours , ” “ San Francisco weather , ” “ cafes near me , ” and other queries that make Google the front threshold to the internet for billions of mass .
My psychometric test run with ChatGPT Search was quite frustrating at times , and it made me witting of just how many keyword searches I perform in a day . I could n’t faithfully feel information using short queries , and for the first clock time in years , I actually long for Google Search .
Join us at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
Exhibit at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
Do n’t get me wrong : Google has declined in quality for the last decade or so , largely because it ’s been inundate with ad , SEO , and confutable AI summaries . Still , I preserve opening Google in a freestanding window during my test because ChatGPT Search could n’t get me a correct answer or WWW page .
I typed in “ Nuggets score ” to check up on how a alive NBA plot between the Denver Nuggets and the Minnesota Timberwolves was going . ChatGPT told me the Nuggets were gain ground even though they were in reality mislay , and demonstrate a Timberwolves grade that was 10 points lower than it really was , grant to a Google result at the same time .
Another time , I tried “ earnings today , ” to check the company reporting quarterly results that could strike stock certificate prices on Friday . ChatGPT told me that Apple and Amazon were reporting their resolution on Friday , even though both companies had already report a 24-hour interval sooner . In other Holy Scripture , it hallucinated and made up information .
In another trial , I typecast in a tech executive ’s name to find their physical contact information . ChatGPT render me a summary of the person ’s Facebook visibility , and hallucinated a link to their LinkedIn page , which produced an error notification when I dawn it .
Another metre , I typed in “ baggy denim jeans , ” hoping to shop . ChatGPT Search described to me what baggy denim jeans were in the first place ( a definition I did n’t need ) , and recommended I go to Amazon.com for a nice dyad .
I could go on , but you get the thought . Broken links , hallucinations , and random answer define my first day using ChatGPT Search .
This was not an peanut launching for OpenAI . Sam Altman praise the feature for being “ really in force , ” even though he ’s known for minimise his inauguration ’s AI capabilities . The ground this sentence is unlike may have something to do with search being one of the biggest businesses on the internet , and OpenAI ’s version could be a real threat to its gravid rival , Google .
To be fair , Google Search is a 25 - year - onetime product and ChatGPT Search is brand new . In ablog post , OpenAI says it plans to improve the characteristic based on substance abuser feedback in the come month , and it seems more than probable this could be a significant arena of investiture for the inauguration .
To its credit , ChatGPT Search is rather good at answering long , write - out research questions . Something like , “ What American professional sport conference has the most diversity ? ” is n’t a question you could easily answer with Google , but ChatGPT Search is pretty adept at scraping multiple websites and receive you a becoming reply in just a couple of second . ( Perplexityis also somewhat good at these questions , and its search product has been around for well over a year . )
Compared to the traditional version of ChatGPT , which already had web access , the hunting feature feel like a better interface for browsing the web . There are more clean links to the sources where ChatGPT gets its information now — for news stories , ChatGPT will be tapping the medium company that it ’s beenstriking all those licensing dealswith .
The job is that most searches on Google are not such foresightful questions . To really replace Google , OpenAI needs to improve these more practical , short searches the great unwashed are already seduce throughout their twenty-four hours .
OpenAI is not timid about the fact that ChatGPT Search conflict with light enquiry .
“ With ChatGPT search , we ’ve observed that user lean to start asking interrogation in more natural ways than they have in the past with other hunt tools , ” said OpenAI spokesperson Niko Felix in a financial statement email to TechCrunch . “ At the same clip — web navigational enquiry — which tend to be short , are quite common . We plan to improve the experience for these types of interrogation over time . ”
That said , these short keyword enquiry have made Google indispensable , and until OpenAI nonplus them correct , Google is still give way to be the lynchpin for many masses .
There are a couple reason why OpenAI might be contend with these poor enquiry . The first is that ChatGPT relies on Microsoft Bing , which is widely regarded as an subscript railway locomotive compared to Google .
The second reason is that with child language models may generally just not be well - suit to these short prompting . LLMs typically need fully written - out questions to produce effective solution , because that help oneself create a stiff statistical pattern for them to complete : it does n’t know that hoi polloi searching for “ cotton fiber socks ” are almost all trying to shit for them , rather than learn about the origin of the garment . Perhaps there needs to be some re - prompting — running brusque question through an LLM as a longer inquiry — before ChatGPT Search can do such lookup well .
Though OpenAI has only now release its search product , Perplexity ’s own AI search putz isalready serving 100 million search queries a week . Perplexity has also been touted as a “ Google slayer , ” but it runs into the same problems with short queries .
Aravind Srinivas , the chief operating officer of Perplexity , talk about howpeople practice his product differentlycompared to Google Search at TechCrunch Disrupt . “ The average act of Holy Writ in a Google question is somewhere between two and three , ” he say at the event . “ In Perplexity , it ’s around 10 to 11 words . So clearly , more of the custom in Perplexity is people coming and directly being able to ask a question . On the other script , at Google , you ’re typing in a few key words to instantly get to a sure link . ”
I think the fact that masses are not using these products for web seafaring represent a openhanded problem than OpenAI or Perplexity are letting on . It means that ChatGPT Search and Perplexity are not replacing Google Search for the task it ’s best at : web navigation .
alternatively , these AI product are occupy a new niche , surface information that gets swallow in traditional search . Do n’t get me wrong , that ’s valuable in its own right .
OpenAI and Perplexity both claim they will solve on getting better at these brusk query . Until then , I do n’t think either of these products can to the full replace Google . If OpenAI want to replace the front doorway to the cyberspace , it has to make a practiced one .
