Topics
Latest
AI
Amazon
Image Credits:Bryce Durbin / TechCrunch
Apps
Biotech & Health
Climate
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman visits “Making Money With Charles Payne” at Fox Business Network Studios on December 04, 2024 in New York City.Image Credits:Mike Coppola / Getty Images
Cloud Computing
Commerce Department
Crypto
endeavour
EVs
Fintech
fund-raise
Gadgets
Gaming
Government & Policy
Hardware
layoff
Media & Entertainment
Meta
Microsoft
privateness
Robotics
surety
Social
Space
Startups
TikTok
Transportation
Venture
More from TechCrunch
event
Startup Battlefield
StrictlyVC
newssheet
Podcasts
video recording
Partner Content
TechCrunch Brand Studio
Crunchboard
reach Us
On Monday , Elon Musk , the world ’s richest man , offeredto corrupt the nonprofit that in effect governs OpenAI for $ 97.4 billion . The unsolicited buyout would be financed by Musk ’s AI troupe , xAI , and a consortium ofoutside investor , per a letter sent to California and Delaware ’s attorneys general .
OpenAI CEO Sam Altmanquickly dismissed Musk ’s bid , and take it as a prospect to publicly dunk on him .
“ no thank you , but we will grease one’s palms Twitter for $ 9.74 billion if you desire , ” Altman write in apost on Xjust hour after reports emerge of Musk ’s offer for OpenAI . Musk owns X , the social meshwork formerly know as Twitter ; he paid roughly $ 44 billion for it in October 2022 .
The two have a history . Musk is an OpenAI co - founding father , and both he and xAI are currently require in a lawsuit that alleges that OpenAI occupy in anticompetitive behavior , among other things .
But Altman ’s rejection of a $ 97.4 billion putsch whirl is more complicated than just saying “ no thanks , ” harmonise to bodied governance expert who spoke with TechCrunch .
Stalling OpenAI’s nonprofit conversion
For screen background , OpenAI was founded as a nonprofit before transitioning to a “ capped - lucre ” structure in 2019 . The non-profit-making is the sole contain stockholder of the cap - profit OpenAI potbelly , which retains conventional fiduciary responsibility to the nonprofit ’s charter .
OpenAI is now in the process of restructuring — this time to a traditional for - profit party , specifically a public welfare corporation — in a bid to raise much more capital . But Musk — who isnotorious for drowning his opposition in legal troubles — may have stalled the transition and raised the price of OpenAI ’s nonprofit with his bid .
DelawareandCalifornia‘s attorneys general have requested more selective information from the ChatGPT Creator about its programme to convert to a for - profit benefit corporation . The spot also forces it to consider outside bids badly .
OpenAI ’s board willalmost sure as shooting refuse the dictation , but Musk has been setting the phase for next legal and regulative battle . He ’s already attempting to stall OpenAI ’s for - profits conversionvia an injunction , for illustration . The bid is likely an alternative offer , of sort .
Now , OpenAI ’s board will have to demonstrate that it ’s not undercut OpenAI ’s nonprofit organization by turn over the nonprofit ’s assets , including IP from OpenAI ’s proprietary research , to an insider ( e.g. Sam Altman ) for a steep discount .
“ Musk is throw a spanner into the works , ” say Stephen Diamond , a attorney who represented Musk ’s opponents in incarnate governance battle at Tesla , in an interview with TechCrunch . “ He ’s exploiting the fiduciary obligation of the nonprofit board to not undercut the asset . [ Musk ’s bid ] is something OpenAI has to compensate attention to . ”
OpenAI is said to be gearing up for a funding round that wouldvalue its for - profit subdivision at $ 260 billion . The Information report thatOpenAI ’s nonprofit is slated to get a 25 % stakes in OpenAI ’s for - net .
With his dictation , Musk has signal there ’s at leastone group of investorswilling to pay a sizable agiotage for OpenAI ’s non-profit-making wing . That puts the gameboard of music director in a stiff smear .
Grounds for rejection
Still , just because Musk throw out an eye - popping offer does n’t mean that OpenAI ’s nonprofit has to take on .
incorporated jurisprudence impart tremendous self-assurance to incumbent boards to protect against unasked coup d’etat bids , according to David Yosifon , a Santa Clara University prof of incarnate governance police .
OpenAI could make the pillowcase that Musk ’s bid is a unfriendly takeover attack given that Musk and Altmanaren’t the sound of friends .
The troupe could also argue that Musk ’s offering is n’t believable because OpenAI is already in the midst of a corporal restructuring appendage .
Another approach OpenAI could take would be challenging Musk on whether he has the pecuniary resource . As The New York Times greenback , Musk ’s wealthiness is mostly tied to his Tesla inventory , mean thatMusk ’s investment partnerswould have to append much of the $ 97.4 billion total .
OpenAI ’s board may necessitate to critique Musk ’s offer to amply asses whether it aline with the nonprofit ’s commission , not just specific financial or strategic goals , accord to Scott Curran , the former worldwide counsel to the Clinton Foundation . That means Musk ’s offering could be weighed against OpenAI ’s mission : “ to ensure that artificial oecumenical intelligence information – AI systems that are broadly overbold than human being – benefits all of humanity . ”
“ When Altman posted that reception [ on X ] , that was probably done without legal counselling , ” Yosifon said . “ It ’s not good for a regulator to see that kind of dismissive , knee - jerky tweet . ”
Raising the value for OpenAI assets
The display panel is probable to side with Altman . intimately all the manager join afterAltman was briefly dismiss , thenrehired , by the nonprofit ’s dining table in late 2023 . Altman himself is also a card member .
If nothing else , Musk ’s bid may erect the possible market value of the OpenAI nonprofit ’s assets . That could force OpenAI to raise more Washington than it earlier counter , and complicate talks with the inauguration ’s exist angel . It could also dilute the value of stakes hold by OpenAI investor in the for - profit sleeve , including major spouse such as Microsoft .
That ’s sure to ire Altman , who ’s been work with investors for months to determine how to pretty make up the nonprofit .
The inwardness is : OpenAI ’s corporate restructuring plans just got more complex .
