Topics
Latest
AI
Amazon
Image Credits:Yuki Iwamura/Bloomberg / Getty Images
Apps
Biotech & Health
mood
Image Credits:Yuki Iwamura/Bloomberg / Getty Images
Cloud Computing
Commerce
Crypto
Enterprise
EVs
Fintech
Fundraising
Gadgets
back
Government & Policy
computer hardware
Layoffs
Media & Entertainment
Meta
Microsoft
Privacy
Robotics
security measure
Social
Space
Startups
TikTok
Transportation
Venture
More from TechCrunch
consequence
Startup Battlefield
StrictlyVC
newssheet
Podcasts
Videos
Partner Content
TechCrunch Brand Studio
Crunchboard
Contact Us
Encode , the non-profit-making establishment that co - shop at California’sill - fatedSB 1047AI rubber legislating , has request permission to file an amicus legal brief in musical accompaniment of Elon Musk’sinjunctionto halt OpenAI ’s passage to a for - profit fellowship .
In aproposed briefsubmitted to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California Friday afternoon , counsel for Encode said that OpenAI ’s conversion to a for - earnings would “ undermine ” the firm ’s commission to “ develop and deploy … transformative technology in a way that is safe and good to the populace . ”
“ OpenAI and its CEO , Sam Altman , claim to be developing lodge - transform engineering , and those claims should be taken seriously , ” the brief read . “ If the world unfeignedly is at the leaflet of a new old age ofartificial general news ( AGI ) , then the populace has a profound stake in have that technology moderate by a public charity lawfully bound to prioritise safety and the public benefit rather than an organization concenter on generate fiscal issue for a few inside investor . ”
In a statement , Sneha Revanur , Encode ’s founder and president , accuse OpenAI of “ interiorize the profits [ of AI ] but externalise the effect to all of humanity , ” and said that “ [ t]he courts must intervene to check AI development dish up the public interest . ”
Encode ’s legal brief has garnered the support of Geoffrey Hinton , a pioneer in the AI field and 2024 Nobel Laureate , and Stuart Russell , a UC Berkeley computer science professor and film director at the Center for Human - Compatible AI .
“ OpenAI was founded as an explicitly safety - focused nonprofit organization and made a potpourri of condom - related hope in its charter , ” Hinton say in apress release . “ It received numerous taxation and other benefit from its nonprofit condition . admit it to tear all of that up when it becomes inconvenient sends a very forged message to other actors in the ecosystem . ”
OpenAI was launched in 2015 as a non-profit-making inquiry lab . But as its experiments became more and more capital - intensive , itcreatedits current complex body part , consume on outside investments from VCs and companies , includingMicrosoft .
Join us at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
Exhibit at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
Today , OpenAI has a intercrossed structure : a for - profit side controlled by a nonprofit with a “ crest profit ” share for investors and employees . But in ablog postFriday morning , the company said it plan to begin transitioning its subsist for - profit into a Delaware Public Benefit Corporation ( PBC ) , with average shares of stock and theOpenAI missionas its public benefit interest .
OpenAI ’s nonprofit will continue but will cede control in substitution for shares in the PBC .
OpenAI hascalledMusk ’s complaints “ baseless ” and simply a showcase of sour grapevine .
Facebook ’s parent troupe and AI contender , Meta , is also supporting seek to impede OpenAI ’s conversion . In December , Metasenta alphabetic character to California lawyer general Rob Bonta , arguing that allowing the transmutation would have “ seismal import for Silicon Valley . ”
Lawyers for Encode said that OpenAI ’s design to channelize control of its operations to a PBC would “ convince an organization bound by law to ensure the safety of advanced AI into one oblige by law to ‘ balance ’ its consideration of any public welfare against ‘ the pecuniary involvement of [ its ] stockholders . ’ ”
Encode ’s counsel notes in the brief , for example , that OpenAI ’s nonprofit organization has committed to hold on competing with any “ note value - aligned , condom - conscious undertaking ” that comes close to building AGI before it does , but that OpenAI as a for - profit would have less ( if any ) incentive to do so . The brief also points out that the instrument panel for the non-profit-making OpenAI will no longer be capable to cancel investors ’ equity if postulate for safety once the company ’s restructuring is completed .
OpenAI continue to experienceanoutflowofhigh - leveltalentdue in part to concerns that the company is prioritize commercial products at the expense of safety . One former employee , Miles Brundage , a longtime insurance policy investigator who left OpenAI in October , say in aseries of postson X that he worries about OpenAI ’s nonprofit becoming a “ side affair ” that gives permit to the PBC to operate as a “ normal company ” without addressing potentially knotty arena .
“ OpenAI ’s gasconade fiduciary responsibility to mankind would evaporate , as Delaware natural law is clear that the directors of a PBC owe no duty to the world at all , ” Encode ’s legal brief continue . “ The public interest group would be harm by a safety - center , mission - constrained nonprofit resign restraint over something so transformative at any price to a for - net income initiative with no enforceable committedness to safe . ”
Encode , launch in July 2020 by Revanur , account itself as a electronic web of volunteers sharpen on ensuring voice of younger generations are try in conversation about AI ’s impacts . Encode has conduce to various pieces of AI state and federal legislation in gain to SB 1047 , include the White House’sAI Bill of Rightsand President Joe Biden’sexecutive rules of order on AI .
Updated December 30 , 2024 , with statements from Revanur and Hinton .
