Topics
late
AI
Amazon
Image Credits:SpaceX
Apps
Biotech & Health
Climate
Image Credits:SpaceX
Cloud Computing
DoC
Crypto
enterprisingness
EVs
Fintech
fund-raise
Gadgets
Gaming
Government & Policy
Hardware
layoff
Media & Entertainment
Meta
Microsoft
Privacy
Robotics
security measure
Social
distance
Startups
TikTok
Transportation
speculation
More from TechCrunch
event
Startup Battlefield
StrictlyVC
Podcasts
video
Partner Content
TechCrunch Brand Studio
Crunchboard
Contact Us
SpaceX has filed a lawsuit against a California government agency this week after the trunk rejected a proposal of marriage to increase the caller ’s launches from the state ’s coastline to 50 per year .
The California Coastal Commission ( CCC ) made its decision at an October 10 meeting , despite the U.S. Air Force ( USAF ) indorse the plan on the grounds that more launches of Starlink and Starshield , the defense - focused whole , are critical to interior security .
In the lawsuit , SpaceX says that the commission lease in “ naked political discrimination ” when some commissioners quote the political body process of CEO Elon Musk , while also attempting to unlawfully influence federal agency activity . The CCC declined to comment for this story . SpaceX did not immediately respond to TechCrunch ’s asking for comment .
The first part of the ill has gotten most of the headlines , and SpaceX will need to prove in lawcourt that the commission ’s determination was substantially influenced by Musk ’s politics . But the second part is arguably more substantial : What is the final legal authority over launch activities on a defense reaction al-Qaeda , and do those activities count as federal or individual when direct by a commercial entity on behalf of the Department of Defense ( DoD ) ?
SpaceX and the USAF say that launching metre at Vandenberg Space Force fundament is a “ Union agency natural process ” because of the capacity of Starlink and the ship’s company ’s launches of other national security payloads , even though Starlink is also a commercial-grade product .
Under this interpretation , the Air Force would simply need to submit a certification express that the purport launches are consistent with United States Department of State policy .
But the commission turn down this characterization of SpaceX launch , give that the company also set in motion commercial payloads and sells Starlink to the world-wide public , with the way fence that increase launches would require the company to give for a “ coastal development permission ” ( CDP ) with the CCC .
Join us at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
Exhibit at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
Staff at the commissionrecommended that the commissioners concurwith the USAF . They reason that the Air Force had committed to implementing protective measures against sonic booms and pointed out a lack of grounds that increasing launch from 36 to 50 per year would have inauspicious environmental effects . The commission will have another chance to consider launch increases soon ; it is require that SpaceX and the USAF will look to increase launches again , to 100 per yr .
Commissioners were far from unanimous in their rejection of SpaceX ’s design — the final suffrage was 6 - 4 against — and most cited their opinion that the launches were primarily a individual , not Union , natural process and as such required a CDP . But it is truthful that some commissioner specifically charge to Musk ’s political activity .
“ We ’re linking the secret and the world , ” Commissioner Mike Wilson enounce . “ This company is own by the rich individual in the existence with direct mastery of what could be the most all-encompassing communication theory system of rules on the major planet . Just last hebdomad that person was speak about political retribution on a national stage , ” he say , referring to Musk ’s appearance at a presidential rally for Donald Trump in Pennsylvania . “ We ’re talk about the promotion of this engineering and a human being that has so much business leader over that , and I just desire to acknowledge that . ”
SpaceX lawsuit also cite a program line from commissioner Gretchen Newsom , who described how Musk has been “ skip about the area , spew and tweeting political falsehoods and assault FEMA while claiming his desire to help the hurricane victims with free Starlink access to the internet . ”
She go on to applaud the USAF ’s willingness to dramatize additional environmental protective measures but said these should be pick by SpaceX : “ These item should be the duty and burden of SpaceX , not the military and taxpayers undertaking these oversights to the welfare of SpaceX , ” she said .
The dispute raise an important stop about the difference between federal and individual action , especially as the U.S. government across civil and defense agencies increasingly procures services from secret caller rather than buy or owning the equipment themselves ( for example , rather than the DoD possess and operating a planet communications meshing for interior security and the intelligence agency community , it purchases capacity from SpaceX ) .
SpaceX obviously believes that its commercial launches are federal agency activities , de jure speaking . The company is asking the Central District of California court to feel the charge ’s rejection of the program illicit .
