Topics
Latest
AI
Amazon
Image Credits:TechCrunch
Apps
Biotech & Health
mood
Cloud Computing
Commerce
Crypto
go-ahead
EVs
Fintech
Fundraising
Gadgets
Gaming
Government & Policy
ironware
Layoffs
Media & Entertainment
Meta
Microsoft
Privacy
Robotics
Security
societal
Space
Startups
TikTok
conveyance
Venture
More from TechCrunch
consequence
Startup Battlefield
StrictlyVC
Podcasts
video recording
Partner Content
TechCrunch Brand Studio
Crunchboard
Contact Us
TikTok confront an uncertain fate in the U.S.once again . A bill include a deadline for TikTok parent company Bytedance to divest within nine months or face a ban on app stores to disperse the app in the U.S.,was signed by President Joe Biden on Wednesdayas part of broader legislation include military aid for Israel and Ukraine . The White House ’s favourable reception come fleetly afterstrong two-party favourable reception in the Houseand a 79 - 18 Senate vote Tuesday in favor of moving the bill forward .
TikTok is based in Los Angeles and Singapore but is have by Formosan tech giant ByteDance . That human relationship has raised eyebrows among U.S. officials , who discourage that the app could be leverage to further the sake of an adversary . The bill ’s critics argue that the U.S. is unfairly targeting a well - loved societal mesh when the government could be dealing with household issues that directly do good Americans .
What happened in the Senate?
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer , who has the major power to set the chamber ’s priorities and round up Democrats for a unified suffrage , initially saidthat the Senate “ will review the lawmaking when it come over from the House . ”
The Senate at first seemed far from presenting a united front against TikTok . Some Republican China hawks like Sens . Josh Hawley and Marsha Blackburn were pushing their sleeping room of Congress to take up the bill . On the popular side , Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman Mark Warner issued a joint financial statement with his Republican commission counterpart , Marco Rubio , in support of a hale sale or Bachelor of Arts in Nursing for TikTok .
“ We are united in our business about the national security threat posture by TikTok — a platform with tremendous power to regulate and separate Americans whose parent caller ByteDance remains legally required to do the bidding of the Chinese Communist Party , ” Warner and Rubio enounce in an emailed statement . Their Senate committee , which is frequently brief on home security matters , is particularly relevant fall in the nature of the concerns verbalise by TikTok ’s critic in Congress .
Late Tuesday , the Senate approvedthe $ 95 billion aid computer software — including aid for Taiwan and humanistic assistance for Gaza — that also turn back the much - debated TikTok forbiddance .
What happened in the House?
In March , the House Energy and Commerce Committee introduced a new bill contrive to pressure ByteDance into selling TikTok . The bill strike off a fresh push by the U.S. government to separate the company from its Formosan ownership or storm it out of the body politic .
Join us at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
Exhibit at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
The eyeshade , have it away as theProtecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act , would make it illegal for computer software with ties to U.S. adversaries to be distributed by U.S. app stores or supported by U.S. vane host . Within the bill ’s definitions , ownership by an entity based in an opponent land , like ByteDance in China , counts .
In words of the card , which goes on to name TikTok explicitly , “ it shall be outlaw for an entity to distribute , keep , or update ( or start the distribution , maintenance , or updating of ) a foreign adversary assure applications programme . ” If the invoice became jurisprudence , Apple ’s App Store and Google Play could not legally distribute the app in the U.S.
The bill , which many of its depreciator reasonably describe as a “ banning , ” would pull ByteDance to betray TikTok within 270 days — close to nine calendar month — in order for the app to uphold operating here . There can also be a 90 - day extension given to the society if “ significant progress ” is being made to deal . It also authorise the president to have oversight of this physical process to check that it result in the company in dubiousness “ no longer being control by a extraneous adversary . ”
After get air current of the bill ’s swift and sudden progress in Congress , TikTok pushed back with a heap in - app message to U.S. users , complete with a clitoris for calling their representative .
“ Speak up now — before your government unclothe 170 million Americans of their constituent right to free facial expression , ” the message read . “ countenance Congress cognise what TikTok intend to you and tell them to vote NO . ”
In spitefulness of TikTok ’s decision to nettle up its users — or perhaps because of it — the posting to force ByteDance to deal TikTok overhaul through the House Energy and Commerce Committee with a 50 - 0 balloting . The tight - tracked bill passed a full voter turnout in the House on March 13 .
Prior to the right to vote , subcommittee membershad a classified briefing with the FBI , the Justice Department and Office of the Director of National Intelligence at the behest of the Biden governance , Punchbowl News reported .
President Biden also explicitly said that he would sign the vizor if it make his desk . “ If they pass it , I ’ll bless it , ” Biden tell a group of reporters . And Biden observe through with that statement in sign the bill Wednesday .
Why does the U.S. say TikTok is a threat?
To be decipherable , there is currently no public grounds that China has ever tapdance into TikTok ’s stores of data on Americans or otherwise compromised the app .
Still , that fact has n’t stopped the U.S. political science from highlighting the possibility that China could if it want to . The Chinese government has n’t been shyabout go hands - on with company in the country orkeeping critics from its business concern biotic community in business .
FBI director Chris Wray once cautioned that user might not see “ outward signs ” if China were ever to meddle with TikTok . “ Something that ’s very sacred in our country — the difference between the individual sphere and the public sphere — that ’s a line that is nonexistent in the way the CCP operates , ” Wray said in a Senate hearing last class .
TikTok has vehemently denied these accusal . “ Let me tell this unequivocally : ByteDance is not an broker of China or any other country , ” TikTok chief operating officer Shou Zi Chew said last yr during a disjoined hearing with the House Energy and Commerce Committee .
To TikTok ’s credit , if China wanted to get its hands on entropy about U.S. drug user , Beijing could well turn to data point agent whoopenly trade trove of drug user datum around the Earth with little oversight .
Because the U.S. has not produced any public grounds to back up its serious claims , there ’s a major disconnect between how pol feel about TikTok and how most Americans do . For many TikTok users , the U.S. crackdown is just one more way thatpoliticians are out of touching with youthful peopleand do n’t understand how they utilize the internet . For them — and other sceptic of the U.S. government activity ’s claim — the situation looks like complete political posturing between two countries with bad blood , sometimes with a elan of racism .
The US administration ramp up its pressure crusade against TikTok
Where did this idea come from?
The campaign to squeeze ByteDance to sell TikTok to a U.S. fellowship start with an executive order during the Trump administration . Trump ’s threats against the company climax in a design to force TikTok to deal its U.S. operations to Oracle in late 2020 . In the process , TikTok pooh-pooh an acquisition whirl from Microsoft butultimately did n’t sell to Oracle , either , in spite of Trump ’s effort to steer the acquisition to do good close friend and Republican mega presenter Larry Ellison .
The executive action ultimately peter out in 2021 after Biden consume agency . But last year , the Biden governance pick up the billy , step up a pressure campaign against the app along with Congress . Now that campaign look to be back on track .
Oddly , former President Donald Trump , who himself induct the idea of a drive TikTok sale four years ago , is no longer in support of a TikTok crackdown . Trump explained his sharp about - face on TikTok by highlight the benefit a ban or squeeze sales event could have on Meta , which suspend the former president ’s score over his role in inciting fury on January 6 .
“ Without TikTok , you may make Facebook bigger , and I consider Facebook to be an enemy of the multitude , ” Trump told CNBC . Trump ’s line on TikTok may have changedfollowing a late meeting with billionaire Republican donor Jeffrey Yass , who owns a 15 % stake in TikTok ’s Taiwanese parent company ByteDance .
What’s TikTok’s response to the potential ban?
There is some strong bipartisan congressional support for regulate TikTok , but things are still pretty complex . The most obvious complicatedness : TikTok is enormously pop and we ’re in an election year . TikTok has 170 million user in the U.S. and they are n’t likely to quietly find out as Congress effectively bans their favorite source of amusement and information .
TikTok ’s creators and their follower likely wo n’t go quietly . TikTok accounts with zillion of follower have a build - in chopine for organizing against the terror to the app that connect them to their community and facilitates brand deals and advertizement income .
TikTok itself would also surely mount a strong legal challenge against the forced sales event , much as it did when the Trump organisation previously taste to attain the same matter through executive natural process . TikTok also litigate when Montana attempted to enact its own banat the state grade , which at last lead ina Union judge publish an injunctionand blocking the effort as unconstitutional .
Our chief operating officer Shou Chew ’s response to the TikTok prohibition : pic.twitter.com / l0RAPJMobK
— TikTok Policy ( @TikTokPolicy)April 24 , 2024
“ This legislation has a predetermined outcome : a total ban of TikTok in the United States , ” TikTok voice Alex Haurek told TechCrunch in an emailed statement . “ The political science is attempting to rifle 170 million Americans of their inbuilt right to complimentary expression , ” Haurek said , foreshadowing the massive public shout that could result .
The cultural range of TikTok is so great that Biden is campaigning on TikTok , even as the White House calls the app a national security threat .
Even though the White House has now signed off on the legislation , the U.S. outline to force ByteDance to sell TikTok could still die — an upshot that may or may not leave in a ban . China has antecedently stated that it would fight a forced sale of TikTok , which is well within the Formosan government ’s right succeed anupdate to the country ’s export convention in late 2020 .
Beyond Congress and the courts , TikTok hold a unmediated line to a monolithic glob of the American electorate and a fleet of Maker who command many millions of fast followers . Those lever of business leader should n’t be underestimated in the fight to total .
Still , it ’s difficult for TikTok to more effectively organize these millions . Though the X chopine , when it control as Twitter , was highly efficient as a chemical mechanism to share breaking news , TikTok ’s algorithms make it less effective as a mean value of understanding what is happening minute by minute . Though TikTok user say it has become a author of intelligence — among adults , those age 18 to 29 are most likely to say they receive their newsworthiness on a regular basis on TikTok — that information tends to be extremely targeted and asynchronous . While many users may know something is brewing in Washington , it ’s likely they are less aware of the step required to fight it , making it harder for TikTok to mobilize them .
This Wiley Post was originally posted March 13 , and has been update as the legislation move forward .
